| 1 min readEducation

Stanford expert reframes the classroom screen time debate

Education scholar Hari Subramonyam encourages a closer look at how students use devices, not just how much time they spend on them.

Students on screens in the classroom
As parents, educators, and lawmakers explore limits on educational technology in the classroom, Stanford scholar Hari Subramonyam says the focus on screen time is misguided. | Allison Shelley for EDUimages

Laptops, tablets, and apps have become fixtures of K-12 classrooms, a shift that accelerated with the COVID-19 pandemic as instruction moved online. Now a backlash is building as parents and educators question the impact of all that screen time, and lawmakers are beginning to look at ways to limit the use of these devices in the classroom.

But when it comes to educational technology, the focus on screen time is misguided, says Hari Subramonyam, an assistant professor at Stanford Graduate School of Education (GSE), faculty affiliate at the Stanford Accelerator for Learning, and faculty fellow at the Stanford Institute for Human-Centered AI (HAI). 

“The real problem is teachers don’t have ways to observe or measure the intellectual work that is happening when children engage with technology,” says Subramonyam, whose research explores ways to design technology effectively for learning. “Technology is just another tool if you use it well.”

Here, Subramonyam talks about how classroom technology has changed in a short span of time, the problem with research into its impact on learning, and why the focus on screen time distracts from other issues facing students and educators.

Hari Subramonyam, smiling, with short dark hair, wearing a red, white and navy plaid shirt, in front of a blurred sandstone background.

Hari Subramonyam | Courtesy Stanford Graduate School of Education

How did we get to the point where the use of things like tablets and laptops in the classroom has become such a flashpoint?

In the early 2000s, technology was much more purpose-built and focused, where classroom technology was meant solely for classroom purposes, and it was heavily vetted before it was brought into the classroom. Around that same time, Nicholas Negroponte at MIT started the “one child per laptop” program, which launched a whole movement around making technology cheaper and more accessible for students everywhere. 

The capabilities of technology also really began to expand at that time, with devices now having multiple functions and social media taking off. It became harder to limit kids to a dedicated tool used in the classroom, and kids could be watching videos and accessing social media through these devices. So there was the realization that we need to start figuring out some policies to regulate their use. 

But then the pandemic happened, and we needed a way to communicate with students, deliver instruction, and assess their learning. Now we’re at a point where these devices have become deeply ingrained into the classroom environment, and we’re at somewhat of an impasse between needing edtech and putting limits on it.  

Much of the debate around edtech in the classroom centers on the amount of screen time. Is that a fair concern?

Screen time is the primary proxy right now, and I don’t think it’s the best. There’s no perfect measure, but screen time is not indicative of the intellectual work that a student is doing. 

Two students can each spend three hours a day on a laptop doing very different things. One is tackling ambitious problems and producing something new, while the other is just passing time.

There are studies that measure screen use and student performance and find a correlation suggesting that more screen time leads to worse outcomes. But screen use happens alongside many other factors. With any intervention, some subset of students do well and others don’t, and motivated learners often compensate for poor instruction or other circumstances. It’s hard to isolate the effect of the technology itself. 

Where might the use of technology be most helpful for student learning? 

Technology is most beneficial if it helps you go from understanding to creating things. A key characteristic of intelligence is the ability to build and use tools, and edtech is just another tool – it should allow us to do more ambitious things, allow us to be more expressive. 

Say you’re teaching the concept of friction. You could give students some text about it, a formula, and some problem-solving tasks, or you could ask them to design the most frictionless sled or ski slope. Using technology to design something ambitious is much more beneficial than using it for rote instruction or recall.

Technology is most beneficial if it helps you go from understanding to creating things.

Are there ages where screens might be especially useful, or especially concerning?

I tend not to put an age limit on things. The more ambitious the learning experience is, the more it benefits from technology, where you move from understanding a concept toward creating something with it. 

What concerns me is instant gratification. With AI, you could create something like a magazine or newspaper in 20 minutes. But a project like that should teach you how to communicate with an audience, how to organize information, how to structure content, how to promote engagement – using AI, you would be offloading all of that. Technology is useful for creation if the user retains the constitutive decisions in the process. 

One big selling point for classroom tech has been the promise of personalized learning, especially for kids with learning disabilities. Do you see that panning out?

It could. So far the kind of personalization we mostly see is asking a child whether they like basketball or the beach, then teaching something like buoyancy by using a basketball analogy. But there’s a lot more to it. 

In my lab, we’re doing a lot of research in this area. We’ve interviewed special education teachers and paraeducators and parents of children with disabilities, and came away with a much more expansive notion of what it means to personalize learning for a child. It’s personalizing everything from motivation to classroom management to transitions between subjects to self-regulation and classroom interactions. We have about 50 different dimensions of what it means to personalize learning, and we’re working on ways to use technology to operationalize that.

Personalization isn’t only about students with learning disabilities. That is the core idea behind universal design: Instead of designing instructions for the average student and retrofitting accommodations, you build flexibility in from the start, and everyone tends to benefit. Several of the dimensions we identified could apply to everyone in the classroom: connecting learning objectives to a purpose the student cares about, calibrating productive struggle before it turns into frustration, helping students regulate their attention and emotions, and personalizing how they are assessed. 

How can we address concerns about technology overuse while still preparing kids for a world where devices are everywhere, in every area of life?

There is a tension. Someone recently told me about a high school intern who had been taught so firmly not to use AI that she refused to use it when they wanted her to.

What’s crucial is helping students develop judgment about when and how to use technology. I call it cognitive literacy: understanding how learning happens and what you lose if you don’t build expertise. The question students should ask is, What am I losing or gaining if I use technology to learn this? 

For teachers, I’d suggest asking not how much screen time students have, but what technology is displacing. Is it displacing students’ attention, or their ability to do the work themselves? Is it displacing interactions with their peers? Then weigh how important those things are to learning and to human flourishing.

For more information

This story was originally published by Stanford Graduate School of Education.

Writer

Carrie Spector

Share this story