Women whose breast cancers need estrogen to grow are often treated for five or more years with medications to lower estrogen production or block its effects. Broadly known as endocrine therapy, the medications can’t be taken during pregnancy or while breastfeeding; premenopausal women wishing to start or grow their families must pause the treatment for months or years.
Ideally, these women resume endocrine therapy as soon as possible to reduce the risk of breast cancer recurrence. Indeed, a clinical trial of several hundred premenopausal women with hormone-responsive breast cancers who paused their endocrine therapy to attempt pregnancy concluded that nearly three-quarters resumed the treatment and only about 9% of participants experienced a recurrence of their cancer in the three years after childbirth.
A new study led by researchers at Stanford Medicine challenges that finding. In a retrospective analysis, the researchers found that only about one-third of women with hormone receptor-positive breast cancer resumed endocrine therapy after delivery, and only about two-thirds resumed regular breast imaging (which is also paused during pregnancy and breastfeeding) to detect recurrence. Furthermore, nearly 20% of the women saw their breast cancers recur at some time during the subsequent decade.
“This is about twice as high as we would expect in these younger women, and it suggests that failing to meet these therapeutic guidelines is contributing to poorer outcomes,” said Julia Ransohoff, MD, a clinical fellow in hematology and oncology. “We need to do a better job of understanding barriers to resumption of care and help this population follow through with their treatment, particularly when breast cancer rates in this age group are increasing.”
Ransohoff is the lead author of the study, which was published online Feb. 13 in JAMA Oncology. Allison Kurian, MD, professor of medicine and of epidemiology and population health, is the senior author of the research.
“It’s always important to understand how guidelines play out in a real-world setting,” Kurian said. “Clinical trial participants tend to be highly motivated and may be more likely to adhere to treatment recommendations. But we are interested in outcomes for all our patients – that’s where the rubber really meets the road. And in this context, I was surprised to see that the rate of treatment resumption was so low.”
Ransohoff, Kurian and their colleagues used a Stanford Medicine-maintained research database called Oncoshare that integrates medical records from community and academic medical systems in the Bay Area to identify 215 women who were diagnosed with breast cancers from stage 0 to stage 3 between January 2000 and October 2024 and who later became pregnant. The median age at diagnosis was 33.6 years. Of these women, 161, or 75%, were eligible for hormone therapy and 130 were eligible for breast imaging (women who had both breasts removed as part of their initial treatment were ineligible).
Only a third complete treatment
Forty-eight women with hormone receptor-positive breast cancer never initiated endocrine therapy. Among the 113 who began endocrine therapy, only 36 (32%) completed five years or more. Among the 81 who paused their endocrine therapy for pregnancy (with a median duration of 21 months), 36 (32%) resumed the therapy.
Although the study didn’t address the reasons a person might choose to avoid or truncate endocrine therapy, the researchers point to a variety of possibilities.
“This set of drugs can really impact a patient’s quality of life,” Ransohoff said. “They can cause menopausal symptoms like hot flashes, disturbed mood and sleep, as well as joint pain, which can affect sexual health as well. The people in our study are also going through all the hormone changes and stress that go along with being a new parent.”
Among the 130 women eligible for regular breast imaging to screen for recurrence (those who had not undergone bilateral mastectomy), 87 (67%) resumed imaging after delivery.
“It’s common to think, Oh, I’m done with chemotherapy, now endocrine therapy and ongoing imaging is the easy part,” Kurian said. “But in reality, you’ve finished the sprint; you are not done with the treatment marathon.”
The researchers hope that their study serves as a foundation for larger studies focused on understanding barriers to adherence in breast cancer patients of different backgrounds and geographic regions. They hope to develop a prospective study incorporating a patient questionnaire about treatment expectations, challenges and adherence.
“This is a great opportunity for in-depth discussions with our patients to learn how we can better help them,” Ransohoff said.
“Even in older women, the rates of adherence to five years of endocrine therapy are much lower than we would like – somewhere around 50%,” Kurian said. “These are hard drugs. We are asking them to do hard things. But these women are young, with young families, and we want to be particularly intensive in maintaining their wellness, even during the chaos and life changes of a growing family.”
For more information
Researchers from the Palo Alto Medical Foundation Research Institute and the University of California, San Francisco, contributed to the work.
The study was funded by the National Institutes of Health (grants P30CA124435, HHSN2612018000321, HHSN2612018000151, HHSN2612018000091, UL1TR003142, UM1TR004921 and UM1TR004921), the Breast Cancer Research Foundation, the Susan and Richard Levy Gift Fund, the Suzanne Pride Bryan Fund for Breast Cancer Research, the Jan Weimer Junior Faculty Chair in Breast Oncology, the Regents of the University of California’s California Breast Cancer Research Program, the BRCA Foundation, the G. Willard Miller Foundation, the Carole and Alan Kushner Charitable Fund, the Nancy McDaniel PlayForHer Fund, the California Department of Public Health, the Palo Alto Medical Foundation, the Chan Zuckerberg Biohub, the Terri Brodeur Breast Cancer Foundation and the ECOG-ACRIN Cancer Research Group.
This story was originally published by Stanford Medicine.
Media contact
Krista Conger
Tel 650-725-5371
kristac@stanford.edu